How Functional Benefits and Naturalness Shape Beverage Preferences
The Market Challenge
The beverage industry is experiencing a significant transformation, driven by shifting consumer preferences toward healthier alternatives. Functional sodas and premium flavored sparkling waters are at the forefront of this change, offering natural ingredients, reduced sugar content, and functional benefits such as prebiotics, vitamins, and electrolytes.
But how much do these attributes influence purchasing decisions? Do functional benefits significantly impact consumer choices, or is naturalness the real key driver? Moreover, should premium flavored sparkling water brands integrate functional claims to remain competitive?
Leveraging over 30,000 consumer reviews and insights generated by Sensia’s AI, this analysis provides concrete answers to these critical questions.
Key Questions and Short Answers
| Question |
Short Answer |
| Are functional benefits key drivers for choosing a soda or sparkling water? |
Yes, but only when paired with strong taste appeal. While digestive health benefits (e.g., prebiotics in Olipop, apple cider vinegar in Poppi) attract health-conscious consumers, taste remains a dominant factor. |
| How important are naturalness claims (no artificial sweeteners, clean label) in this decision process? |
Extremely important. Across both categories, beverages with natural ingredients and no artificial sweeteners receive higher ratings and positive sentiment. |
| Do premium flavored sparkling water brands need to integrate functional attributes to stay competitive? |
Not necessarily. Premium sparkling water consumers prioritize refreshing taste and real fruit ingredients over added functionalities. However, clean-label positioning remains critical. |
These conclusions will be expanded below, supported by AI-generated insights from consumer reviews.
1. Functional Benefits: Do They Drive Consumer Choice?
💡 Key Finding: Functional Claims Matter—But Only When Taste Delivers
Consumer interest in functional beverages is growing, particularly for digestive health, metabolism support, and hydration. However, taste remains the top priority.
🔍 AI-Generated Insights on Functional Beverages
| Brand |
Functional Claim |
Positive Sentiment (%) |
Negative Sentiment (%) |
Overall Score |
| Olipop Ginger Lemon |
Prebiotics for digestive health |
83.3% |
13.3% |
5.15 |
| Poppi Raspberry Rose |
Apple cider vinegar benefits |
81.2% |
16.0% |
4.59 |
| Zevia Cherry Cola |
Zero sugar, stevia-sweetened |
83.6% |
9.3% |
4.42 |
| Culture Pop Strawberry Rhubarb |
Probiotic soda |
70.7% |
29.3% |
3.55 |
👉 Consumer Trend:
- Digestive health is a key motivator – Consumers appreciate brands like Olipop for prebiotic benefits.
- Stevia-based sodas (e.g., Zevia) receive mixed feedback – While valued for being sugar-free, some consumers dislike the aftertaste.
- Taste is the dealbreaker – Products with strong health claims but weak flavors (e.g., Culture Pop) suffer from low scores and high negative sentiment.
🚀 Takeaway for Brands
- Combine functional claims with great taste – Functional benefits alone do not drive sales; they must come with a satisfying flavor experience.
- Educate consumers on functional benefits – Skepticism exists, and brands must reinforce their claims with clear messaging.
2. Naturalness: The Ultimate Decision Driver
💡 Key Finding: Natural Ingredients & Clean Label = Higher Satisfaction
Consumer reviews reveal a strong preference for clean-label products—those without artificial sweeteners or additives. Products with real fruit juice and minimal processing consistently receive higher ratings.
🔍 AI-Generated Insights on Naturalness
| Brand |
Key Ingredient Positioning |
Positive Sentiment (%) |
Negative Sentiment (%) |
Overall Score |
| Spindrift Grapefruit |
Real fruit juice, no artificial sweeteners |
87.6% |
10.6% |
5.73 |
| San Pellegrino Momenti |
Fruit juice-based, no artificial sweeteners |
95.3% |
3.8% |
6.29 |
| Bubly Lime |
Flavored sparkling water, no sweeteners |
87.6% |
9.8% |
5.64 |
| Topo Chico Sabores Tangerine Ginger |
Infused with natural fruit extracts |
91.9% |
7.0% |
6.64 |
👉 Consumer Trend:
- Real fruit juice = Higher positive ratings (Spindrift, San Pellegrino).
- Artificial sweeteners = Lower trust & weaker scores (Culture Pop, Poppi).
- Minimalist ingredients resonate best – Consumers prefer simple, clean formulations.
🚀 Takeaway for Brands
- Naturalness is more important than functionality. Brands should emphasize clean ingredients over complex functional claims.
- Positioning around "no artificial sweeteners" is a key driver—consumers actively seek transparency and simplicity.
3. Should Premium Flavored Sparkling Waters Adopt Functional Claims?
💡 Key Finding: Not a Necessity—But Clean Label Positioning is Essential
Unlike functional sodas, premium sparkling water buyers prioritize refreshing taste, real fruit ingredients, and an enjoyable drinking experience over added health claims.
🔍 AI-Generated Insights on Premium Sparkling Waters
| Consumer Motivation |
Impact on Choice |
| Refreshing taste |
🔥 #1 purchase driver |
| Real fruit juice |
👍 Boosts brand trust |
| Functional claims (electrolytes, vitamins) |
🤷 Low impact on decision |
Premium brands like San Pellegrino, Spindrift, and Topo Chico perform well due to their natural ingredients and strong taste appeal, not necessarily because of functional claims.
🚀 Takeaway for Brands
- Functional claims are not essential for premium sparkling waters—but a clean label is non-negotiable.
- Prioritize ingredient transparency—natural flavor extracts and fruit juices drive higher consumer trust and satisfaction.
Final Takeaways: What Should Brands Do?
| Key Consumer Drivers |
Actionable Recommendations |
| Taste & Refreshment |
Ensure that functional products still deliver bold and enjoyable flavors. |
| Natural Ingredients |
Highlight real fruit juices and emphasize no artificial sweeteners. |
| Health Benefits |
Educate consumers on digestive & metabolic advantages—but don’t compromise taste. |
| Clean Label Positioning |
Transparency and ingredient simplicity matter more than added functionalities. |
🔎 Sensia’s AI-Powered Insights in Action
The ability to analyze 30,000+ reviews across multiple brands showcases how AI-driven consumer insights can provide brands with data-backed strategies. Sensia not only reveals what consumers say, but also why they say it, helping brands refine their positioning and innovation roadmap.
Want to see the full analysis? Request access to the detailed study here.